Jerry Harrison of the Talking Heads had this to say about drum machines:
In information theory, the theory that was developed by Claude Shannon, there is this idea that in any given message the amount of information in that message is reflected in by how expected the message is. And if its close to 100% that the message is going to say ‘yes’, then a message that says ‘yes’ is giving you far less information than a message that says ‘no’. And I feel that the mind, which is trained to see differences in our environment(because danger is usually a change in an environment), that when we listen to music with drum machines, that actually because it becomes totally expected when a snare drum beat is, or kick drum beat is particularly in disco music, your mind begins to tune out the drum machine itself and hear the music around it. And that it’s almost like the drums could be ultra loud and yet you would still hear everything around it. If those were real drums you would say ‘the drums are too loud, I can’t hear that,’ but because of your mind’s ability to say, ‘I know that’s there, what else is there?’ that it kind of changed the dynamic of music.
You can listen to his words in context online from a BBC Radio archive- the original interview with Roger Linn is available for streaming and download.
The complaint that I hear most frequently from people when I play them dance music is that it ‘all sounds the same’. A lot of 4/4 music does sound similar. But you could make the same complaint about lots of music when it comes to forms and shapes, so that remark doesn’t really hold up in my opinion. I often share lunchtime discussions with Yair about music and criticism and he had a few thoughts on how people approach art and music. Coming from any background, a person brings their own set of experiences and knowledge to bear on a subject, and dance music is ontologically different from rock or punk or rap, just as different as those styles are from each other….
…I’d really like to take Ishkar’s Guide to Electronic Music and expand it to include the last 5 or so years of electronic dance music. Ishkar’s guide is a wonderful guide to the history and many different styles of electronic dance music, thanks to Ponce de Leon for the tip.)
